Given below are two statements: (A): The density of the copper (⁶⁴Cu₂₉) nucleus is greater than that of the carbon (¹²C₆) nucleus. (R): The nucleus of mass number A has a radius proportional to A¹/³.

❓ Question

Given below are two statements:

  • Assertion (A): The density of the copper (64Cu29^{64}\text{Cu}_{29}) nucleus is greater than that of the carbon (12C6^{12}\text{C}_6) nucleus.

  • Reason (R): The nucleus of mass number AA has a radius proportional to A1/3A^{1/3}.


🖼️ Question Image

Given below are two statements:  (A): The density of the copper (⁶⁴Cu₂₉) nucleus is greater than that of the carbon (¹²C₆) nucleus. (R): The nucleus of mass number A has a radius proportional to A¹/³.


✍️ Short Solution

We need to check (1) whether A is true, (2) whether R is true, and (3) whether R explains A.

🔹 Step 1 — Is the Reason (R) true?

Empirically and from the liquid-drop model, the nuclear radius is given by

R=r0A1/3,

where r01.2 fmr_0\approx 1.2\text{ fm}
So R is true.


🔹 Step 2 — Use R to examine the Assertion (A)

Density of a nucleus ρ\rho ≈ mass / volume.

Thus

ρ  =  massvolume    AA  =  constant.

Therefore, to first approximation nuclear density is independent of AA — nuclei have roughly the same average density (≈ 2.3×1017kg/m32.3\times10^{17}\,\text{kg/m}^3 or about 0.160.16 nucleons/fm³). So the density of 64Cu^{64}\text{Cu} is not significantly greater than that of 12C^{12}\text{C}; they are approximately the same. Hence Assertion (A) is false.


🔹 Step 3 — Does R explain A?

Although R is true and is used above to show that density scales out (so densities are roughly constant), it actually contradicts the idea in A that copper’s nuclear density is greater. So R does not support A. R is true but does not explain A (instead R shows why A is false).


🧮 Image Solution

Given below are two statements:  (A): The density of the copper (⁶⁴Cu₂₉) nucleus is greater than that of the carbon (¹²C₆) nucleus. (R): The nucleus of mass number A has a radius proportional to A¹/³.


✅ Conclusion & Video Solution

  • Reason (R): True — nuclear radius R=r0A1/3R=r_0A^{1/3}

  • Assertion (A): False — average nuclear density is approximately constant across nuclei, so copper’s nucleus is not appreciably denser than carbon’s.

  • R does not explain A.

R is true, A is false; R does not explain A.​


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ideal Gas Equation Explained: PV = nRT, Units, Forms, and JEE Tips [2025 Guide]

Balanced Redox Reaction: Mg + HNO₃ → Mg(NO₃)₂ + N₂O + H₂O | JEE Chemistry

Centroid of Circular Disc with Hole | System of Particles | JEE Physics | Doubtify JEE